Airbnb vs Long-Term Rental in Melbourne: Which Earns More?

Should you rent your Melbourne property to a long-term tenant or list it on Airbnb? Short-term rentals can earn more per year, but they also cost more to run and come with different rules. The right choice depends on your property, your suburb and how hands-on you want to be.

This guide compares the two on income, costs, Victorian rules and who each option suits, so you can see where each one wins.

Which earns more: Airbnb or a long-term tenant?

Short-term rentals often bring in more gross income than a long-term lease, because you charge a nightly rate that rises with demand. But gross income is not what you keep. A fair comparison looks at what is left after fees, running costs and empty nights.

The main things that decide the result are your occupancy (how many nights you are booked), your nightly rate, and how well the property is presented. A well-styled property in a busy location, priced to match demand, can do very well. A poorly presented property in a quiet street may do no better than a long-term rental. To see what is realistic, read our guide to how much you can earn from Airbnb in Melbourne.

What Airbnb costs to run

Short-term rentals have more costs than a long-term lease, and you should include them before comparing.

  • Management. Full-service Airbnb management typically costs more than traditional property management. Our fee is 17% to 20% plus GST, compared with 5% to 12% for a long-term rental. See what Airbnb management costs in Melbourne for what that covers.

  • Setup. The property needs furniture, linen and styling to appear well in listings. This is a one-off cost.

  • Ongoing costs. Cleaning, restocking, maintenance, utilities and internet are usually part of running a short-stay property.

  • Short stay levy. Victoria charges a levy on short stays, covered below.

  • Empty nights. Unlike a lease, income stops on nights nobody books.

Victorian rules to know about

Both options are regulated, and the rules have changed recently. This is general information, not legal advice, so check the current rules before you decide.

Short stay levy. Victoria charges a 7.5% levy on short stays of less than 28 days, from 1 January 2025. The booking platform collects it on platform bookings, and the host pays it on direct bookings. Stays in your principal place of residence are exempt. Check the State Revenue Office website for the current details.

Apartment rules. If your property is in an apartment building, the owners corporation can ban short stays by special resolution, although the ban cannot apply to an owner's principal place of residence. Read our guide to Airbnb in a Melbourne apartment and owners corporation rules before you list.

Tenancy law. Victoria's rental reforms started on 25 November 2025. Rental bidding is banned, and landlords can no longer end a tenancy without a valid reason, including at the end of a fixed-term lease. Notice periods for rent increases and some notices to vacate are now 90 days. Properties also have to meet minimum standards before they are let. Consumer Affairs Victoria explains the full list of changes. These rules make it harder to take a long-term rental back when you want it, which is one reason some owners prefer short stays.

Who suits Airbnb, and who suits a long-term rental?

Airbnb tends to suit you if:

  • Your property is in a popular area close to the city, cafes, trams or the beach.

  • You want the option to use the property yourself.

  • You are happy to price flexibly, or to use a manager who does it for you.

  • You can accept some months earning less than others.

A long-term rental tends to suit you if:

  • You want steady, predictable income with the least involvement.

  • Your property is in a quieter area with less visitor demand.

  • You do not want to furnish and style the property.

  • Your apartment building does not allow short stays.

Many owners switch once they see how much a well-run short-term rental can earn. If you are unsure, a free assessment can tell you which fits your property.

Frequently asked questions

Is Airbnb more profitable than a long-term rental in Melbourne?

Often it earns more gross income, but not always. After management fees, running costs, the short stay levy and empty nights, the result depends on your location, occupancy and presentation. Compare the net figures for your own property, not just the headline nightly rate.

Can I switch from a long-term tenant to Airbnb?

Yes, but not while a tenant has a lease on the property. Under Victoria's rental rules you need a valid reason to end a tenancy, so plan the timing carefully and get advice before you give notice.

Who looks after guests, cleaning and pricing if I list on Airbnb?

You can do it yourself or use a manager. At AG & Co. we handle the listing, pricing, guest support, cleaning and maintenance, and send you a monthly statement. See our BnB Management page.

Where we manage Airbnbs

We manage short-term rentals in Collingwood, Fitzroy, St Kilda and South Melbourne. If you are thinking of buying an investment property for short-term rental, our Airbnb Buyer's Advisory can help.

Not sure which is right for your property?

Tell us about your property and we will give you an honest view of whether short-term rental would earn more than a long-term lease. Call Alan on 0421 128 602 or contact us for a free assessment.